Scale Imbalance in Digital Projects
18 Sep. 2017
An explanation of diseconomies of scale and why modern, automated e-commerce models are better equipped to expand profitably.
A condition whose delayed remedy comes at a cost is known as diseconomies of scale, or, in Arabic, tabdhīrāt al-ḥajm. It is the stage at which a business activity enters into a cumulative rise in costs that exceeds the cumulative rise in sales of that activity’s goods or services. In other words, in order to preserve the quality of the product or service, the rate of increase in total costs exceeds the corresponding rate of increase in total revenues. As a result, the profit-margin ratio relative to revenues continues to decline even as revenues themselves rise.
There is no doubt that expanding sales is one of the primary objectives of profit-seeking businesses, as it is the optimal strategy for increasing profit margins. According to the graph above, the business activity experiences an increase in profit margin alongside an increase in sales. Yet the rate of that increase begins to decline continuously after passing the turning point of scale, at which the activity enters a phase of uneconomic scale. Theoretically, this scale leads to the break-even stage, where total costs equal total revenues. Continuing to increase sales beyond that point causes losses to rise continuously.
There are several reasons why a business model may enter a phase of uneconomic scale, such as poor planning, weak coordination, or congestion. Under such circumstances, business owners are compelled to raise costs in order to maintain the quality of the product or service and preserve customer satisfaction. Accordingly, costs rise at a faster rate than the increase in the number of customers or clients, simply to maintain the same level of satisfaction. Since expansion lies at the heart of the problem, the business planner must take into account the mechanism of expansion within the business model, such that the impact of costs on revenues is cumulative rather than fixed.
To ensure that the business model in an expansion plan does not succumb to uneconomic scale, it is necessary to ensure that the change in total revenues exceeds the change in total costs in a cumulative way relative to production volume, rather than merely exceeding costs multiplied by production quantity. For example, suppose a business specializes in selling product “X” through employee “C,” with a daily production and sales capacity of 4 units of X to 4 customers. In that case, if sales expand to 12 units of X, we would need 3 employees of type C as a variable cost. But what if expansion reaches 8,000 units of X? There is no doubt that we would then need 2,000 employees of type C as a variable cost to meet demand. Equality between the rate of increase in variable production cost and the rate of increase in output would, in this case, be accompanied by other costs — whether fixed or additional variable costs — that continue to rise in order to stabilize product quality and customer satisfaction. It is this rise that pushes the activity into the phase of uneconomic scale.
But what if the business model in the expansion plan were different, بحيث that 4 units of X require 1 employee C, 10 units require 2 employees, 20 units require 3 employees, and 40 units require 4 employees? This is possible through the use of modern technologies characterized by dynamism and automation. In such a case, the higher the total production quantity, the higher the productivity rate of employee C. In other words, declining cost coincides with rising output.
This is the very axis of success for e-commerce ventures, which have incorporated such scaling principles into their expansion plans through the use of the latest technologies, strategies, and operational mechanisms within their core business models. E-commerce is far more than a تجارة identical to another conventional business that merely resembles it in its method of selling. E-commerce is more than a trade activity that is easy to market and reach. It is the form of business best positioned to use principles that reduce the marginal cost of expansion, thereby strengthening economic scale against rising costs. It is also the model most capable of improving its operating mechanisms so as to manage processes that raise revenues and lower costs simultaneously, in pursuit of the highest possible profit margin.
There is no doubt that expanding sales is one of the primary objectives of profit-seeking businesses, as it is the optimal strategy for increasing profit margins. According to the graph above, the business activity experiences an increase in profit margin alongside an increase in sales. Yet the rate of that increase begins to decline continuously after passing the turning point of scale, at which the activity enters a phase of uneconomic scale. Theoretically, this scale leads to the break-even stage, where total costs equal total revenues. Continuing to increase sales beyond that point causes losses to rise continuously.
There are several reasons why a business model may enter a phase of uneconomic scale, such as poor planning, weak coordination, or congestion. Under such circumstances, business owners are compelled to raise costs in order to maintain the quality of the product or service and preserve customer satisfaction. Accordingly, costs rise at a faster rate than the increase in the number of customers or clients, simply to maintain the same level of satisfaction. Since expansion lies at the heart of the problem, the business planner must take into account the mechanism of expansion within the business model, such that the impact of costs on revenues is cumulative rather than fixed.
To ensure that the business model in an expansion plan does not succumb to uneconomic scale, it is necessary to ensure that the change in total revenues exceeds the change in total costs in a cumulative way relative to production volume, rather than merely exceeding costs multiplied by production quantity. For example, suppose a business specializes in selling product “X” through employee “C,” with a daily production and sales capacity of 4 units of X to 4 customers. In that case, if sales expand to 12 units of X, we would need 3 employees of type C as a variable cost. But what if expansion reaches 8,000 units of X? There is no doubt that we would then need 2,000 employees of type C as a variable cost to meet demand. Equality between the rate of increase in variable production cost and the rate of increase in output would, in this case, be accompanied by other costs — whether fixed or additional variable costs — that continue to rise in order to stabilize product quality and customer satisfaction. It is this rise that pushes the activity into the phase of uneconomic scale.
But what if the business model in the expansion plan were different, بحيث that 4 units of X require 1 employee C, 10 units require 2 employees, 20 units require 3 employees, and 40 units require 4 employees? This is possible through the use of modern technologies characterized by dynamism and automation. In such a case, the higher the total production quantity, the higher the productivity rate of employee C. In other words, declining cost coincides with rising output.
This is the very axis of success for e-commerce ventures, which have incorporated such scaling principles into their expansion plans through the use of the latest technologies, strategies, and operational mechanisms within their core business models. E-commerce is far more than a تجارة identical to another conventional business that merely resembles it in its method of selling. E-commerce is more than a trade activity that is easy to market and reach. It is the form of business best positioned to use principles that reduce the marginal cost of expansion, thereby strengthening economic scale against rising costs. It is also the model most capable of improving its operating mechanisms so as to manage processes that raise revenues and lower costs simultaneously, in pursuit of the highest possible profit margin.
Abdullah Al-Salloum
Thoughtful messages and inquiries are always welcome. Send a message
Answers
How does scale imbalance in digital projects affect the economy?
Its effect appears in how costs, incentives, and resources are managed, and in the economy's ability to turn decisions into sustainable value. The direct context is diseconomies of scale and why modern, automated e-commerce models are better equipped to expand profitably.
How can data governance move from a general idea to something measurable?
Digital government needs data governance because service quality depends on clear ownership, exchange, protection, and integration across entities. When accountability is ignored, the idea becomes a limited procedure that does not change the wider path.
How can government automation move from a general idea to something measurable?
Automation success is measured by saved time, reliable decisions, less manual intervention, and a better citizen experience. When accountability is ignored, the idea becomes a limited procedure that does not change the wider path.
How can digital transformation move from a general idea to something measurable?
Real digital transformation rebuilds processes, data, and responsibilities; surface digitization changes the interface while leaving complexity intact. When accountability is ignored, the idea becomes a limited procedure that does not change the wider path.
Related articles